Sydney:12/24 22:26:56

Tokyo:12/24 22:26:56

Hong Kong:12/24 22:26:56

Singapore:12/24 22:26:56

Dubai:12/24 22:26:56

London:12/24 22:26:56

New York:12/24 22:26:56

News  >  News Details

A deep dive into this week's gold capital flows: Not all into the US dollar, short-term reversion depends on these signals.

2026-11-20 20:28:30

This week (November 16-20), the gold market experienced a sharp sell-off. Spot gold prices plummeted from near $3,900 at the beginning of the week, briefly falling below the $3,515-$3,550 range on Friday, with a weekly decline approaching 8%-9%, marking the worst weekly performance since March and the most severe weekly drop in nearly eight months. Silver's decline was even more dramatic, with a weekly drop of approximately 14%, while platinum and palladium also suffered significant losses, putting pressure on almost the entire precious metals sector. Such drastic price changes easily lead one to believe of a large-scale capital flight: investors selling gold and flocking to dollar assets. However, this understanding is incomplete, considering ETF holdings and the capital flows in different markets. The decline in gold prices does not perfectly match changes in ETF holdings. While some funds did indeed withdraw from precious metals, a considerable portion of the selling stemmed from adjustments to leveraged futures positions and liquidity needs arising from declines in other assets. This means that the types of funds and trading motives involved behind this round of gold price declines are quite complex. To determine whether funds will return to the gold market, we first need to figure out who was selling and where the money went after they were sold. 图片点击可在新窗口打开查看

I. ETF Funds: Not the Massive Collapse as Expected

Gold ETFs are an important window for observing the movement of medium- to long-term investment funds. Taking the world's largest gold ETF, SPDR Gold Shares (GLD), as an example, its gold holdings were approximately 1044.12 tons as of November 19th. It's worth noting that GLD holdings did not decrease continuously this week despite the decline in gold prices. On November 16th and 17th, fund holdings actually increased by approximately 1.7 tons and 2.5 tons respectively, with a more significant redemption occurring on the 18th, a single-day decrease of approximately 4.56 tons, while holdings remained essentially flat on the 19th. Looking at these days together, the overall change in holdings was quite limited. Some tracking data even shows that GLD still recorded weekly net inflows of millions to hundreds of millions of dollars during the sharp drop in gold prices. Global gold ETFs exhibit similar characteristics. Recent capital outflows have slowed significantly. Data shows that global physical gold ETF holdings decreased only slightly by approximately 1.8 tons last week, the smallest decline in nearly four months, with a slight capital inflow even seen in the European market. While redemptions continue in North America, their scale is far from sufficient to explain the dramatic drop in gold prices. ETF holdings remain relatively stable, indicating that long-term investment funds have not collectively withdrawn during this correction. In particular, some funds chose to hold their positions during the rapid decline in gold prices, even increasing their holdings on dips. This contrasts with the apparent panic selling in the market. Therefore, the main pressure on gold prices is more likely from funds with stronger trading characteristics. Leveraged long positions accumulated in the futures market earlier faced liquidation pressure after the price decline, and some investors needed to sell highly liquid assets such as gold to offset losses in other markets. The fact that ETF holdings have not collapsed on a similar scale also suggests that this sell-off was not solely driven by long-term investors collectively being bearish on gold.

II. Where did the funds mainly go?

Looking at the performance of various assets this week, US dollar cash and US dollar-denominated assets are the main directions that gold funds may shift towards. However, there is another force in the market that cannot be ignored: margin pressure and cash demand brought about by the stock market decline. The combination of these two forces has caused gold to experience selling pressure in this round of adjustment that exceeds what can be explained by interest rate factors alone. 1. US Dollar Cash and High-Yield US Treasuries: Allocation Shifts Caused by Interest Rate Changes The strengthening of the US dollar is an important background to the pressure on gold this week. The US dollar index continued to rise, approaching a 19-month high, with the DXY once hovering around 103.8-104. At the same time, the yield on 10-year US Treasury bonds remained above 5%, and real interest rates also showed an upward trend. For allocation funds, this change is quite direct. Gold itself does not generate interest, and when US Treasury yields rise and the attractiveness of US dollar assets increases, the opportunity cost of holding gold also increases. Especially for institutional funds that are more sensitive to interest rate changes, it is not surprising that they are reassessing the allocation ratio between gold and US dollar assets. This adjustment of funds is more like an asset reallocation driven by interest rate expectations. 1. A hawkish outlook for Federal Reserve policy has supported the dollar and Treasury yields, weakening gold's previous investment advantages. 2. Margin Calls in Stock Accounts: Some Gold Selling Arises from Passive Liquidation Another easily overlooked factor is the sharp volatility in the stock market. AI and technology stocks experienced significant selling this week, and Asian stock markets followed Wall Street's decline. With losses in stock positions and rising margin pressure, investors often need to raise cash quickly. Gold, with its good liquidity and substantial gains accumulated over a period, naturally becomes a target for liquidation. Such transactions do not necessarily indicate a change in investors' long-term assessment of gold's value. For investors needing to replenish margin or control overall account risk, selling gold may simply be the easiest option at the moment. Even though gold still retains its safe-haven properties, it may be sold off in tandem with other assets during periods of concentrated liquidity pressure. With the year-end approaching, some institutions also face funding arrangements and position adjustments, further increasing short-term liquidity pressure. Therefore, some of the selling in the gold market this week actually reflects a contraction in the risk of the entire investment portfolio. When stocks and other risky assets come under pressure, gold is unlikely to remain completely unaffected. 3. Asian Physical Demand and Localized Bottom-Fishing: Support Remains During the Decline While Western financial markets experienced concentrated selling pressure, the Asian physical market began to show some different signals. After the rapid decline in gold prices, physical demand in India, China, and other regions rebounded, with some consumers and investors viewing the price drop as an opportunity to increase their gold holdings. Central bank gold purchases also continued, providing relatively stable structural demand to the market. This type of buying differs from the trading funds in the European and American financial markets. Physical demand typically focuses more on price levels and medium- to long-term investment value, and the pace of fund entry may not be synchronized with the futures market. Therefore, even if bargain hunting occurs in Asia, it does not mean that it can immediately offset the concentrated selling in European and American markets. Futures positions are also worth noting. While speculative net long positions had previously adjusted, the latest full COT report as of November 10th still shows that speculators are maintaining a net long position overall. Following this week's sharp decline, the exact amount of speculative capital reducing long positions and whether new short positions have been established remains to be seen, pending confirmation in Friday evening's report. Based on currently available information, several opposing forces are still at play in the gold market: dollar assets are attracting some allocation funds, liquidity pressures in the stock market are forcing some investors to sell gold, and physical demand in Asia is providing some support after the price drop. The combined effect of these forces has resulted in this week's dramatic price correction.

III. Will these funds return to gold in the short term? The key is to see what changes occur.

In the short term, expecting a rapid and large-scale return of previously withdrawn funds to gold in the coming weeks to one or two months is unrealistic. First, the interest rate environment for gold has not shown significant improvement. Hawkish expectations from the Federal Reserve continue to strengthen, and market expectations for a 25 basis point rate hike in December are high. Under these circumstances, neither real interest rates nor the US dollar have a reason to immediately reverse course. As long as the attractiveness of dollar assets continues to prevail, interest rate-sensitive funds will find it difficult to quickly change their allocation direction. The situation in the stock market is also important. If the correction in AI and technology stocks has not yet ended, the liquidity pressure from cross-asset deleveraging may continue. Even if some investors remain bullish on gold, they may not have enough funds to increase their positions again. Coupled with year-end liquidity arrangements and position adjustments by institutional funds, gold will need favorable external conditions to attract sustained incremental funds in the short term. What could truly change the flow of funds is primarily the Federal Reserve's policy expectations and real interest rates. If subsequent inflation data shows a significant decline, or if Federal Reserve officials' statements begin to shift towards a more dovish stance, market expectations for rate hikes will cool, and real interest rates may gradually peak. At that time, the relative attractiveness of dollar assets will weaken, and some funds that previously shifted to bonds and cash may reconsider gold allocation. If the dollar index weakens in tandem, this change will provide even more support for gold. Whether the stock market can stabilize is also an important factor. Investors who were forced to sell gold to cover margin calls are more likely to reallocate to precious metals only after the risk pressure on other assets eases. Whether gold's safe-haven and diversification functions can be restored also depends on whether the market has escaped this general liquidity contraction. In addition, price itself will also affect the willingness of funds to enter the market. The area around $3,500 has become a widely watched area. If gold prices gradually stabilize in this area, Asian physical demand, ETF allocation funds, and some bargain-hunting trading funds may form new support. However, the price approaching the technical level that the market is watching does not mean that funds will necessarily enter the market immediately; it is still necessary to observe changes in actual trading volume and open interest. Historically, after gold has undergone interest rate-driven adjustments, once real interest rates show a clear inflection point, the return of funds can sometimes be quite rapid. The fact that current ETF holdings have not yet collapsed significantly means that long-term allocation positions still have a certain degree of stability. This is particularly noteworthy for future market trends: if macroeconomic pressures begin to ease and long-term positions do not show significant outflows during the decline, the conditions for gold to regain investor attention will gradually improve.

IV. Is it possible for funds from other markets to flow into gold?

Potential gold buying isn't limited to existing gold holders. Bonds, stocks, physical commodities, and other alternative asset markets could all become sources of new capital, though the entry conditions and timing may differ. The bond market is one of the most noteworthy areas. Current pressure on gold is largely related to rising US Treasury yields. If future US economic data weakens and market expectations for interest rate cuts increase again, US Treasury yields may fall. For institutional funds that previously favored bond yields, gold's attractiveness may rise again. Especially after real interest rates peak, the relative attractiveness between gold and bonds may change. Stock market flows are more complex. If the stock market experiences a normal correction and then gradually stabilizes, easing investor liquidity pressures, some funds may seek asset diversification and risk hedging, giving gold a chance to regain demand. However, if the stock market continues to fall sharply, accompanied by margin calls and forced liquidations, gold may still be used as a liquidation tool in the short term. Both scenarios seem to indicate a weakening stock market, but their ultimate impact on gold could be completely different. Physical demand and official gold purchases provide another layer of support. The Indian wedding season, Chinese gold consumption, and continued gold purchases by central banks worldwide are all important components of medium- to long-term gold demand. Especially in the Asian market, gold possesses both consumption attributes and long-term value storage and asset allocation attributes. When prices decline significantly, this demand is often more easily activated, forming a buying force distinct from trading funds in the financial markets. Furthermore, the rotation of funds in other commodity and alternative asset markets is also worth noting. When the overall commodity market is under pressure, or investors begin to seek assets with tangible attributes again, gold still retains a certain relative appeal. However, whether these funds will actually enter gold depends on changes in the overall macroeconomic environment and market risk appetite. It's important to recognize that the main contradictions in the current market remain unchanged: high interest rate expectations and a strong dollar continue to suppress gold. Even if there is a possibility of reallocation of funds from other markets, it needs corresponding macroeconomic catalysts. In the short term, what's truly worth tracking are changes in the dollar and real interest rates, the liquidity of the stock market, and whether ETF and futures positions can remain stable after price adjustments. Only when these signals gradually improve will gold be more likely to see a sustained return of funds.
Risk Warning and Disclaimer
The market involves risk, and trading may not be suitable for all investors. This article is for reference only and does not constitute personal investment advice, nor does it take into account certain users’ specific investment objectives, financial situation, or other needs. Any investment decisions made based on this information are at your own risk.

Real-Time Popular Commodities

Instrument Current Price Change

XAU

3570.59

-54.42

(-1.50%)

XAG

42.253

-0.594

(-1.39%)

CONC

82.28

-0.16

(-0.19%)

OILC

91.59

-1.07

(-1.15%)

USD

103.740

-0.200

(-0.19%)

EURUSD

1.0980

0.0013

(0.12%)

GBPUSD

1.3105

0.0018

(0.13%)

USDCNH

6.6790

-0.0107

(-0.16%)

Hot News