Download App

[Standing Off at Poland's Constitutional Court Escalates; Judicial Appointment Dispute Triggers "Coup" Allegations] ⑴ On October 30, local time, the Polish Constitutional Court announced the suspension of its President, Žižekowski, and Vice President, Šokhaniski, for one month. Senior judge Krwin Piotrowski temporarily assumed the court's duties. Subsequently, the court's official account accused the website of being "illegally taken over," claiming the President remained in office and alleging the actions constituted a "coup." ⑵ Polish President Nawroczyk, en route to Senegal, immediately interrupted his trip and returned to Warsaw, stating that "at such a moment, the President must remain in Poland." Upon arrival, he met with the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court and the President of the Constitutional Court and entered the courthouse. ⑶ That evening, a large number of protesters gathered outside the Constitutional Court, some clashing with police. Three people attempting to storm the courthouse were apprehended, and the clashes resulted in multiple injuries. Opposition figures, including Law and Justice party leader Kaczynski, arrived and accused the Tusk government of attempting to seize control of the courts by force. (4) Tusk defended his actions on social media, stating that after "years of lawlessness by the Law and Justice Party," restoring the rule of law required decisive action, and "there was no other way." (5) The root of this standoff lies in a long-standing dispute over judicial appointments: of the judges elected by the majority in the Sejm, Nawrocsky only accepted the oaths of some, while the identities of the remaining judges were not recognized by the president and the court president. Neither side recognized the judges nominated by the other, leading to a near-paralysis of the Constitutional Court. (6) The European Court of Justice previously ruled that the Polish Constitutional Court no longer constituted an "independent and impartial court." The Tusk government used this ruling as a basis to stop publishing court judgments, while the Constitutional Court president refused to accept the suspension, citing the legality of previous appointments. Both sides held differing views on the legal basis. (7) The crisis also showed signs of spillover. The Polish ambassador to China, Kumoch, announced his resignation after the incident, stating that he "could no longer serve the Republic." The Law and Justice Party, on the other hand, invoked the coup clause in the criminal code, demanding that Tusk be held accountable.