Silver investors should focus on vault inventory, not just price.
2026-11-20 00:28:30
If this round of decline stems from an oversupply of physical silver and sluggish sales in the spot market, this would typically be reflected in large warehouse data, but this is not currently the case. London silver inventories at the end of October were lower than the previous month, marking the first decline after six consecutive months of increases. In New York, deliverable inventories corresponding to silver futures remained almost unchanged during the price decline. Meanwhile, India, the world's largest silver consumer, saw its silver import spending in October nearly triple that of September. Based solely on this one month's inventory data, this is a slight positive for silver holders. However, this does not indicate a short squeeze; the next key test will arrive on November 30th—the start date for delivery notices for the COMEX December silver contract. Silver has retreated from its high of $121.67 at the beginning of 2026 and is currently trading around $45.30, with the downward trend continuing. Later on November 18th, silver was trading at approximately $44.93 per ounce, a daily drop of about 5%. The Federal Reserve released hawkish minutes from its last meeting, further fueling market bets on a December rate hike. The gold-silver ratio is approximately 83, meaning one ounce of gold can be exchanged for approximately 83 ounces of silver. The current silver price is down about 37% from its closing price at the end of 2025. London Inventories: First Decrease in Six Months London is the global wholesale trading center for silver, with a large amount of silver bars stored there. Monthly data from the London Bullion Market Association (LBMA) shows that at the end of October, London gold vault inventories were 28,889 tons, equivalent to approximately 928.8 million ounces, a decrease of 3.1 million ounces from the end of September, after five consecutive months of increases. The decline in London inventories largely reflects a change in ownership and storage location of the silver, and does not necessarily mean that the silver has been consumed industrially. Some silver may flow to physical consumption markets such as India, and some may be purchased by ETFs; however, many silver ETFs themselves hold their silver bars in LBMA vaults. Increased holdings only result in a change of holders within the vaults and do not cause a decrease in the total amount of silver in the vaults. Therefore, whether ETF holdings consume publicly available inventory needs to be assessed separately, and the LBMA has not disclosed the specific destination. Gold vault inventories remain ample, but not full, and are about 21% lower than the peak in June 2021. Research firm MetalsFocus estimates that, excluding ETF holdings, there are approximately 267 million ounces of silver in circulation. This global estimate is almost double the non-ETF inventory in London vaults at the time (136 million ounces)—the two estimates have different scopes; the former covers globally circulating silver, while the latter only covers London vaults, making direct comparison meaningless. At the time, MetalsFocus and the Silver Institute referred to this London inventory figure as a "historic low," and weeks after its release, a short squeeze occurred in the London market in October, making it difficult for buyers to obtain physical silver. The two sets of data come from different reports, and the silver targets covered by the statistics are not entirely consistent; furthermore, the 267 million ounce estimate predates the October data, so the two cannot be combined to estimate the latest supply and demand balance. ETFs may also be drawing from this physical inventory. The iShares Silver Trust, whose main inventory is held in London, increased its holdings by approximately 11 million ounces of silver from the end of September to November 10. If this increased silver was taken from London vaults, then the decrease in silver inventory excluding ETFs would be greater than the overall decrease reported by the LBMA. This is the author's inference, as the LBMA does not differentiate between inventory holder structures. New York Market: Inventories Remain Stable Amid Selling Pressure . COMEX is the main US silver futures exchange, where traders lock in silver prices for forward delivery. Its "registered inventory" refers to silver held in warehouse receipts that can be directly used for futures delivery. Exchange data shows that registered inventory was 101.63 million ounces on November 9; CME Group data compiled by MetalCharts shows that inventory was approximately 101.2 million ounces on November 18. Despite a sharp drop in silver prices in just nine days, deliverable physical inventory remained almost unchanged. Open interest refers to the total amount of futures contracts that have not yet been settled. In ounce terms, each ounce of registered inventory currently corresponds to approximately 5.7 ounces of open interest, a ratio unchanged from a week ago. Note: Most open interest positions will be closed out early or rolled over, and not all will proceed to physical delivery. This ratio is for reference only and does not equate to delivery pressure. On November 10th, net long positions held by asset management institutions, primarily hedge funds, were 3,615 contracts, representing long positions minus short positions, near a low level since February 2024. Currently, the scale of bullish bets by these trading institutions is far lower than earlier this year. A low net long position indicates limited overall bullish exposure, but the total open interest reflects significant market divergence; large long and short positions offset each other, making this indicator insufficient to directly predict the potential for forced liquidation. India: Buyers Return India is the world's largest silver consumer, with domestic silver consumption heavily reliant on imports. Traders revealed that at the end of October, the Indian government issued six-month silver import licenses, totaling approximately 6,500 tons, equivalent to 209 million ounces, roughly 90% of India's total silver imports for 2025. According to statistics from Metals Focus and the Silver Institute, India's total silver imports for 2025 are 232.2 million ounces. Import licenses only represent an import quota limit, not a rigid purchase order. At the time the licenses were issued, Indian buyers only needed to purchase at a premium of 45 cents per ounce over the domestic official benchmark price. This relatively low spot premium indicates that in the initial stage of quota liberalization, spot supply was not tight, and there was no concentrated rush to buy. Subsequently, the latest trade data showed marginal improvement: the Indian Ministry of Commerce and Industry announced that silver imports in October reached $1.91 billion, almost three times that of September. This statistic is in monetary terms, not physical tonnage, and silver prices fluctuated between the two months. The month-on-month decline in silver prices in October meant that the same purchase amount could obtain more physical silver; however, due to the lack of official physical tonnage figures, the import amount can only be considered a weak demand signal. October imports were still about 28% lower than in October 2025. October 2025 coincided with a short squeeze in London, during which India made large-scale purchases. The November import data, to be released in mid-December, will be the first full-month data after the new import quotas take effect. What does this mean for silver investors? Inventory data is sending a different signal than price movements. If the decline in silver prices is due to an oversupply of physical silver, vault inventories would typically continue to accumulate. However, in October, London inventories declined while Indian imports increased; by mid-November, deliverable inventories in New York remained stable. Based on this one month's data alone, it provides weak support for the logic that "global silver consumption exceeds production." However, this does not yet prove that the market has experienced a visible shortage. London inventories remain ample, there is no apparent physical delivery pressure in the New York market, and Indian purchases only resumed after months of easing import restrictions. Market analysts generally believe that this round of silver price declines is mainly due to market expectations of a December interest rate hike and a stronger dollar. In their mid-term assessment on November 12, Metals Focus and the Silver Institute continued to predict that silver would experience a supply-demand gap for the sixth consecutive year, with a gap size of approximately 35 million ounces, lower than their April estimate of 46.3 million ounces. The institutions also noted that the supply-demand gap has narrowed somewhat, and there has been physical outflow from ETFs, both of which have eased the tightness in the physical silver bar and coin retail market this year. Several key verification points are approaching: on November 30, buyers holding December contracts will receive delivery notices; December is one of the main delivery months for COMEX. If delivery is stable that month and registered inventories remain around 100 million ounces, it will confirm an overall loose physical market. LBMA's November inventory data will be released around December 7, and India's November import data will be released in mid-December.
- Risk Warning and Disclaimer
- The market involves risk, and trading may not be suitable for all investors. This article is for reference only and does not constitute personal investment advice, nor does it take into account certain users’ specific investment objectives, financial situation, or other needs. Any investment decisions made based on this information are at your own risk.