The credibility of the Federal Reserve's monetary policy is in a dilemma.
2026-11-21 01:20:31
However, the era of great easing is over. The current monetary policy environment faces numerous challenges. Its past performance in addressing these challenges, often far beyond the Fed's control, is becoming increasingly inconsistent. This, in turn, damages the Fed's credibility and reputation. Inflation The Fed states that achieving price stability is its responsibility. However, the Fed has failed to meet its inflation target for six consecutive years. While it still allows households and businesses to make reliable, undistorted decisions, the target is 2%, and the gap will continue to widen over time. Furthermore, Americans are increasingly sensitive to inflation, especially after the pandemic, coupled with concerns about affordability. In an environment of persistently low inflation, the Fed developed a "flexible average inflation targeting" framework. Then came the pandemic, accompanied by massive fiscal spending and supply shocks. This framework was quickly criticized for encouraging the Fed to excessively extend easing policies after the pandemic and was wrongly labeled as "fighting a war." Given economic resilience, demand for artificial intelligence, low unemployment, rising energy prices, and tariffs, inflation appears increasingly entrenched. Of course, if real incomes are squeezed, such as by falling oil prices or cooling AI demand, the possibility of inflation falling back to a more moderate level near the target cannot be ruled out. But this is equally unrealistic. Monetary policy excels at addressing demand shocks. The US economy, however, is primarily suffering from a series of supply shocks, many of which are beyond the Fed's control. The Fed has been somewhat cautious, questioning whether these shocks are merely temporary or can be "read through." But demand appears increasingly robust, and secondary effects are already apparent. Financial conditions can be described as accommodative rather than restrictive. Many believe the Fed is now out of touch. Opinions range from a 50-basis-point increase in the federal funds rate to calls for a 100-basis-point increase. Undoubtedly, the "Fed doctor" must administer stronger medicine. Communication Clear and transparent communication between the Fed and the market is crucial, especially since monetary policy works by transmitting financial conditions to the real economy. This is currently not being done. Chairman Kevin Warsh opposes explicit forward guidance, arguing that the Fed should talk less and listen more to market feedback, rather than the other way around. Most agree that explicit forward guidance is unnecessary unless interest rates are at the zero lower bound. However, they also believe that even if the Fed has been overly explicit in the past, it should still be a significant voice shaping market expectations; and regardless, the market will actively try to decipher the Fed's views, paying attention to the dot plot and Fed speeches. Therefore, they believe the Fed should clearly outline its reaction function. But Warsh's press conference was not considered informative, meaning his views failed to guide the market. Warsh's relative silence—or rather, his skepticism—perhaps meant he didn't need to express a hawkish stance that could anger the ultra-dovish President Donald Trump. In any case, the Fed's communication is now considered to have deteriorated. At a time of rising global yields, this will only exacerbate uncertainty and volatility across the yield curve. The White House and the Treasury The technical debate continues regarding the future direction of the Fed's balance sheet, whether it has overstepped its bounds into the fiscal domain, and what this means for money market management. But the bigger question is what the apparent interdependence between fiscal and monetary policy actually means for the Fed and its independence. Trump continues to call for a significant cut in the federal funds rate to spare the government from soaring interest bills—now exceeding 3% of GDP and higher than annual U.S. defense spending. He continues to downplay the U.S. inflation problem. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has made a rare public intervention in the Fed's monetary policy, calling for rate cuts and arguing for a detached view of rising energy prices. Bessent accelerated the pace of Treasury repurchase agreements to curb rising long-term interest rates, but without success. Warsh has declared himself a defender of the Fed's monetary policy independence, refuting those who believed he would become a Trump "puppet." But Warsh's task force hasn't addressed the elephant in the room. These deficits are supporting demand and inflation, pushing up long-term yields. Beyond suggesting the unsustainability of U.S. fiscal policy, the Fed's timid approach to discussing the impact of fiscal policy on demand, inflation, the yield curve, and monetary policy may be to avoid alarming the president. But these are precisely the Fed's core responsibilities and are crucial to the health of the nation. Are fiscal and financial dominance potential threats to the U.S.? The relationship between the Fed and the Treasury appears far less smooth than before, further exacerbating uncertainty. The Federal Reserve is caught in a dilemma. After six consecutive years of missing its inflation target, it is falling behind in addressing the current inflation challenges facing the United States. These challenges stem primarily from supply shocks—energy, war, immigration crackdowns, AI, tariffs—that the Fed has little power to address. But they now appear to be driving demand. Weakened communication has fueled volatility. A key government unwilling to curb fiscal indulgence is also proving ineffective. The Fed under Warsh is increasingly finding itself on the defensive. (Author Mark Sobel is Vice Chairman and Chief Economist of the Official Monetary and Financial Institutions Forum (OMFIF)).
- Risk Warning and Disclaimer
- The market involves risk, and trading may not be suitable for all investors. This article is for reference only and does not constitute personal investment advice, nor does it take into account certain users’ specific investment objectives, financial situation, or other needs. Any investment decisions made based on this information are at your own risk.